Welcome to PicktheParty, where the real debate happens. You are signed in as guest.

PicktheParty Banner
Home Page View All Current Debates
 
Price Flooring Should Be Allowed

Title:

Price Flooring Should Be Allowed

Created on:

December 11, 2007

As soon as Barkley Heron learned he was one of two winners of the $22 million Canadian lottery jackpot, he cut the price of gas at his service station from $1.15 a liter to 50 cents a liter. Word spread quickly in the town of about 2,300, located on the Alberta border. Trucks and snowmobiles lined up for several blocks to cash in on Heron's gas deal until the tanks ran dry. "We got a large turnout. There was a lineup for a couple of blocks," Heron told CBC News on Sunday as he was refueling the tanks. "By this morning, we emptied the last of it … about 10,000 liters."

Read Entire Report

Agree or Disagree?

52 48
     
  Votes:
56
 



Order By: Oldest First || Newest First
Page 1 of 2 1 2
Registered Independent Respond He cut his prices by some 43% and is still making a slight profit??????? Perhaps the real question people need to be asking is whether there should be a price ceiling on gas to help keep the crooks from robbing us blind.
posted by Cass(350) 7 months and 14 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond I guess I don't understand the problem. If someone wants to operate a business at a loss or a minimal profit, I don't see why the government should step in.
posted by Thor(350) 7 months and 14 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond It's sad that gas station attendents are going to lose their jobs, but you can just as easily argue the other way that the new prices are going to keep just as many consumers from getting into a jam -- and it is only a temporary measure.
posted by Kat(650) 7 months and 14 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond Ummmm. What exactly is price flooring? Putting a limit on the minimum price a business can charge?
posted by corinthians(250) 7 months and 14 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond How would this be any different than a store offering door buster prices on products the day after Thanksgiving?
posted by Bella(350) 7 months and 14 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond With just a few exceptions, medicines and basics after a disaster, etc, a business should be able to charge whatever price they want. That goes for a price that's too high or too low.
posted by Peter(350) 7 months and 13 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond Who on Earth would set the price floor? And how would they decide. I say let them go as low as they want to go.
posted by Kat(650) 7 months and 10 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond In response to Kat:Yeah!!! Finally we agree on something. Unless it's a large company trying to price everyone out of the market so they can become a monopoly, the government has no business butting in.
posted by southboca(700) 7 months and 10 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond In response to Cass:Hmmmm. Yep, does seem rather fishy tbat that big a cut still brings him a profit.
posted by Thor(350) 7 months and 8 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond What a silly idea. Businesses are allowed to charge too little.
posted by mike(100) 7 months and 8 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond In response to corinthians:I've never heard the term before, but that's what I'd assume that it means...kind of the opposite of a price ceiling.
posted by southboca(700) 7 months and 6 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond I think the government should not interfere in such matters and in business it should be left totally on the person doing business.
posted by teammate(550) 5 months and 27 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond In response to Cass: Amen, I'm much more supportive of a "ceiling" than a "flooring". I'm not worried about anyone charging too little for gas right now, when there are so VERY, VERY many people out there charging too much for it.
posted by Lssrof2evils(15) 5 months and 27 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Liberal Respond Well, it is a matter of offer and demand! I remember a guy that in protest did exactly the opposite: He put the price on his gas station at $5 so nobody would go and buy it, and even that way, he got some people going and buying gas from him at that price. I think the demand should determined that, and if they don't want to have more proffit, then the government shouldn't interfere.
posted by SallyDP(300) 5 months and 25 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond I'd definitely support Cass' view, if he still makes a profit surely the issue is with the exorbitantly high prices.

On the other hand, if this were to continue long term, there would be a problem. The local gas station industry could turn into a disaster and this would affect many people, particularly employees who are made redundant. By stopping price flooring, the people it is protecting is the general public as their jobs are safeguarded, it isn't something that offers them no benefit.

There's nothing wrong with what he's doing in this case, however; it couldn't carry on this way without causing damage, therefore I am forced to disagree with regards to allowing it.
posted by carlos92(53) 4 months and 26 days ago City School Board
Order By: Oldest First || Newest First
Page 1 of 2 1 2


Your thoughts on Price Flooring Should Be Allowed :


Home || Contact Us || What We Do || Tutorials || Privacy Policy

 
 
   


 
 
 
     
 
 
 
 
   







Debate on Catholic Church Catholic Church



114 votes, 13 comments
Debate on Tony Blair Tony Blair



84 votes, 22 comments
Debate on Barack Obama Barack Obama



134 votes, 58 comments
 
Debate on Hillary Clinton Won With Tears Hillary Clinton W...



45 votes, 1 comments
Debate on Oprah Winfrey Will Help Obama Surpass Hillary Oprah Winfrey Wil...



44 votes, 1 comments
Debate on Price Flooring Should Be Allowed Price Flooring Sh...



50 votes, 11 comments
  All Debates
 
Censorship Turned ON


PicktheParty is a free online community that allows users to have fun with political discussions while debating everything from current topics to political jokes.

Once a registered member you can post comments, images and videos. Membership also grants our users vote tracking, a message inbox, chances to win prizes and access to various promotions.

PicktheParty does not sell or give away any information we receive.

So quit your filibustering and register!


The US housing market ha...
Illegal immigration legi...
NYC horse drawn carriage...
Judges should be allowed...
Bush will act in time to...
Candy that looks like dr...
The mortgage bailout is...
Americans would be comfo...
  All Debates
 


Invite Your Friends to PTP!
Find a User on PTP


I Never Got My Verification Email
I Forgot My Password

© 2005 Nostalgic Media, All Rights Reserved
PicktheParty™ is a trademark of Nostalgic Media