Welcome to PicktheParty, where the real debate happens. You are signed in as guest.

PicktheParty Banner
Home Page View All Current Debates
 
Mexican Trucks in the US Are a Bad Idea

Title:

Mexican Trucks in the US Are a Bad Idea

Created on:

September 18, 2007

The United States promised in the 1994 North American Free Trade Agreement to allow trucks from Mexico to carry goods directly to any destination in the country. But opposition from labor and environmental groups kept the program on hold until just recently when the first Mexican truck crossed the border bound for North Carolina.

Though the move can result in less transportation costs, the job of checking every truck to cross the border complicates things.

Read Entire Report

Agree or Disagree?

43 57
     
  Votes:
65
 



Order By: Oldest First || Newest First
Page 1 of 2 1 2
Registered Conservative Respond The lack of handoffs could mean considerable cost decreases in the transportation of goods, something that would at least partially be handed t down to consumers. Just as long as we have an agency to check every single one of them crossing the border.
posted by skywalker(247) 11 months and 15 days ago User is an Administrator
Registered Independent Respond I have a hard time believing that our government can be trusted to ensure that what is coming across the borders on these trucks is safe. Do the benefits out weigh the costs?
posted by sweetnothing(387) 11 months and 15 days ago Mayor
Registered Independent Respond I think the two main issues that they will need to knock out are safety and environmental concerns.
posted by Peter(350) 11 months and 15 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond In response to sweetnothing:They used to have to offload everything onto American trucks at the border. My guess is that eliminating that step is going to save a whole lot of money.
posted by Bella(350) 11 months and 15 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond In response to Bella:But it's also going to cut out a lot of American jobs. That's not such a good thing.
posted by Cass(350) 11 months and 15 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond Yeah and i hate to think about whether or not these trucks are going to be as safe as what's already on the road here.
posted by Thor(350) 11 months and 15 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond In response to Thor:And can you even begin to imagine the pollution potential? Yuck.
posted by Kat(650) 11 months and 15 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond Does anybody know whether the truckers are going to be allowed to drive in the US on Mexican licenses? Or will they need to get a license from the US too?
posted by southboca(700) 11 months and 15 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond I heard that the teamsters/unions were trying to get an injunction to block the trucks from crossing the border. Sounds like there's a lot of money/jobs on the line.
posted by southboca(700) 11 months and 14 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond Ooops. Guess Mexican trucks are pretty safe after all. According to federal transportation officials in recent years they have ha a better safety record than their U.S. counterparts.
posted by Peter(350) 11 months and 14 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond The other thing that's nice is it's a max of 100 Mexican trucks and that 100 American trucks will do the same in Mexico. All the trucks have to pass a safety audit and inspection before being allowed to participate in the project.
posted by Peter(350) 11 months and 14 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond In response to Peter:That's certainly good news. A very limited and controlled rollout are the only way to go on such an iffy program.
posted by Cass(350) 11 months and 14 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond Am I the only one who see's an influx of illegal immigrants as a huge possibility if this occurs? And yes, I'd be very concerned about drivers if they did not have a license issued within the US as well. It would have to be a very specific license as well (can only drive trucks for MX Freightlines for example). There would have to be some way to track down drivers who break our laws while on the road. I think this would be a bad idea. I can see way too many negatives, and people trying to take advantage of the situation if it comes to fruition.
posted by mesagirl(10) 11 months and 14 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond Mexicans in the US is a bad idea, why should we let there death trap trucks on our roads. What happens if they have an accident, are they required to carry insurance? And if they are how do we know they are who they say they are. They are currently making up BS IDs to get jobs in the US, how do we know that they won't be driving trucks under false names.

This will be just another way that they will be taking work away from Americans. Since they will be able to travel through the US there will be less truck drivers needed to pick up trailers at the border and move them through the US.

I have said this before and I'll say it again, liberals are killing this country.

I think that instead of trying to make the rules more lax for this type of **** we should be going the other way to the point of abolishing the NAFTA agreement.
posted by Opinionated SOB(45) 11 months and 13 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Registered Independent Respond I stand in an interesting position, having been a dispatcher for a small trucking firm as well as dating a truck driver to even working in a truck stop as a waitress. The general consensus of most of the truckers I have heard is that this will only farther run independent truckers and small trucking companies out of business as rates get cut and freight becomes less available. More then once it has been referred to the selling off or out of America, by our own government. Not to mention the policing of these trucks in safety as well as the shear number of then coming into the US. Then comes the concern of increased drug traffic that might happen. One driver said at this rate in the not to distant future we are looking at being just plain North America vs/ there being three counties that we have now and the only ones making out on the whole thing will be the wealthy. I'm not sure about that...perhaps.. Just seems to me that this once great nations leaders are forgetting why they are in office and who they are there to represent. But then again I'm still waiting for that trickle down theory to reach me.

Remind me again what NAFTA stands for? Cause one might think it is more like * Now America For The Asking.*
posted by angelwolf(2) 11 months and 11 days ago Aspiring Patriot
Order By: Oldest First || Newest First
Page 1 of 2 1 2


Your thoughts on Mexican Trucks in the US Are a Bad Idea :


Home || Contact Us || What We Do || Tutorials || Privacy Policy

 
 
   


 
 
 
     
 
 
 
 
   







Debate on Catholic Church Catholic Church



114 votes, 13 comments
Debate on Tony Blair Tony Blair



84 votes, 22 comments
Debate on Barack Obama Barack Obama



134 votes, 58 comments
 
Debate on Hillary Clinton Won With Tears Hillary Clinton W...



45 votes, 1 comments
Debate on Oprah Winfrey Will Help Obama Surpass Hillary Oprah Winfrey Wil...



44 votes, 1 comments
Debate on Price Flooring Should Be Allowed Price Flooring Sh...



50 votes, 11 comments
  All Debates
 
Censorship Turned ON


PicktheParty is a free online community that allows users to have fun with political discussions while debating everything from current topics to political jokes.

Once a registered member you can post comments, images and videos. Membership also grants our users vote tracking, a message inbox, chances to win prizes and access to various promotions.

PicktheParty does not sell or give away any information we receive.

So quit your filibustering and register!


The US housing market ha...
Illegal immigration legi...
NYC horse drawn carriage...
Judges should be allowed...
Bush will act in time to...
Candy that looks like dr...
The mortgage bailout is...
Americans would be comfo...
  All Debates
 


Invite Your Friends to PTP!
Find a User on PTP


I Never Got My Verification Email
I Forgot My Password

© 2005 Nostalgic Media, All Rights Reserved
PicktheParty™ is a trademark of Nostalgic Media